YAH Brew & Cartel Brewing Expand To Former Tattered Flag Brewery in Middletown, PA

Today I have some interesting jiont venture news coming from YAH Brew and Cartel Brewing & Blending. YAH Brew & Cartel will expand into this new space in Middletown Pennsylvania (Former Tattered Flag Brewing). Here are the full details from YAH Brew Hershey:

FUN ANNOUNCEMENT:
For the last few months, we’ve been working on a pretty rad joint venture project with our friends at YAH Brew…
We are stoked to announce that we have the keys and begun the next stage of bringing this amazing space back to life in Middletown, PA!

We will launch a multifaceted community space that will allow us to use the brewery for both of our brands as well as our collaborative new brand and taproom. We also plan to create a cooperative production facility for other breweries to share and expand their brewing and canning needs and foresee a distillery brand arising in 2026….
All in all, we can’t be more excited about this project and partnering with Justin and Aimee from YAH Brew. More details to follow in the coming weeks…..

This PR From July 17th 2025:

By NAI CIR Press Release – Emma Weikel 717-761-5070 ext 117 [email protected]

Middletown, PA – YAH Brew, a bold and fast-growing female-owned brewery based in Hummelstown, has leased the ground-floor space of the former Tattered Flag Brewery & Distillery in Middletown. Known for its pop culture-inspired beer releases, bold styles, and inclusive community spirit, YAH Brew will use the space to expand production capabilities and support growing demand.

This new location complements the brewery’s existing operations, which include a taproom in downtown Hershey, and brewery/taproom and hoagie shop in Mount Joy. The Middletown expansion marks a major milestone in the brand’s continued growth—reviving a well-known local craft beer destination.
Nik Sgagias, of NAI CIR, represented the landlord in the transaction.

The second floor of the building features a 5,000 SF, fully equipped restaurant space that remains available for lease—offering a rare opportunity for a food and beverage operator to join the heart of Middletown’s evolving culinary and craft beverage scene. To view more about the property, head to the website here: https://circommercial.com/properties/?propertyId=1-South-Union-Street-LEASE.

About NAI CIR
NAI CIR, with offices in Lemoyne and Carlisle, is Central Pennsylvania’s oldest and largest exclusively commercial industrial real estate full-service brokerage firm. Founded in 1970, the firm is consistently ranked as the top producing commercial industrial sales and leasing firm by the Central Pennsylvania Business Journal and by Real Capital Analytics. Our team has been honored as a Philadelphia Region CoStar Power Broker for 25 consecutive years.
NAI CIR is the Central Pennsylvania representative of NAI Global, an international organization of real estate professionals with connections across the world. Our transaction and management professionals are among the most experienced and successful in the business, and our platform ensures that our expertise directly benefits our clients.

About YAH Brew:

YAH Brew is a 90s-themed brewery and taproom located in Hershey, PA. Owned by Justin and Aimee Hoak, it’s known for its nostalgic atmosphere, featuring 90s music videos, pinball machines, and a vibrant, colorful aesthetic. The taproom offers a variety of YAH Brew and other Pennsylvania breweries’ beers, along with cocktails and a food menu that includes items like pizzas, crunch wraps, and tacos. 

Here’s a more detailed look:

Nostalgic Theme:
YAH Brew’s 90s theme is a key part of its identity, appealing to the nostalgia of the Millennial generation. 

Taproom Experience:
The taproom features a fun, interactive space with 90s music videos playing, pinball machines, and a selfie wall. 

Beer and Food:
They offer a wide selection of craft beers, including their own YAH Brew creations and beers from other Pennsylvania breweries. Their food menu includes items like pizzas, crunch wraps, and tacos, and they also offer brunch on Sundays. 

Location:
YAH Brew is located at 251 W. Chocolate Ave in Hershey, taking over the former location of Tattered Flag Distillery and Bar. 

Family-Friendly:
The taproom is family-friendly with two patio spaces available for outdoor dining, and they welcome pets on their front patio. 

Events:
YAH Brew hosts Tuesday night pub trivia and also has a private event space that can accommodate large groups. 

About Cartel Brewing:

Cartel Brewing & Blending is a microbrewery and beer cafe located in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. They focus on traditional beer styles like lagers and English ales, while also exploring innovative flavor infusions and barrel-aged strong ales. Cartel is known for its community-focused approach and plans to open a second location called “The Safe House” in Manheim, Pennsylvania, which will be an “elevated dive bar” with a focus on affordable food and beverages. 

Here’s a more detailed look:

Location:
Cartel Brewing & Blending is based in Lancaster, PA. 

Focus:
They specialize in traditional beer styles like lagers and English ales, while also experimenting with new styles and barrel-aged beers. 

Second Location:
“The Safe House” is planned as a second location in Manheim, PA, aiming to be a welcoming and affordable space with a focus on easy-drinking beers, classic pub fare, and a nostalgic price point. 

Community Focus:
Cartel emphasizes a community-driven approach, aiming to reclaim the term “cartel” in a positive light, potentially through charitable work related to anti-trafficking efforts. 

Joint Venture:
Cartel is also involved in a joint venture with YAH Brew in Middletown, PA, which will include a shared production facility and potentially a distillery brand. 

Expansion:
The expansion to The Safe House is a response to local demand for a neighborhood gathering spot with good beer and food.